We're working on a website which has a custom membership provider implementation instead of the standard Umbraco one, and we have noticed some issues with Forms.
Is the Forms package only meant to be used with the standard membership provider, or is what we found a red herring and that's not the reason forms stopped working anyway? :)
Thank you.
Hello Andrei,
Yes this is a bug and you did pinpoint it down to the right location back to the Core. There is an issue created in the issue tracker that I have fixed in this set of tasks for this sprint, but is currently awaiting internal review from another team member.
Umbraco Forms issue when using custom membership providers?
Hi guys,
We're working on a website which has a custom membership provider implementation instead of the standard Umbraco one, and we have noticed some issues with Forms.
After a user logs in, all the forms stop working. After a brief look, we tentatively narrowed it down to this particular section in the Umbraco core - https://github.com/umbraco/Umbraco-CMS/blob/d50e49ad37fd5ca7bad2fd6e8fc994f3408ae70c/src/Umbraco.Web/Security/MembershipHelper.cs#L851 As you can see, the membership helper (which we believe Forms uses as well) throws an error when the membership provider is not the standard UmbracoMembershipProvider.
Is the Forms package only meant to be used with the standard membership provider, or is what we found a red herring and that's not the reason forms stopped working anyway? :)
Thank you.
Hello Andrei,
Yes this is a bug and you did pinpoint it down to the right location back to the Core. There is an issue created in the issue tracker that I have fixed in this set of tasks for this sprint, but is currently awaiting internal review from another team member.
Follow this issue here for more information - http://issues.umbraco.org/issue/CON-890
Thanks,
Warren
is working on a reply...