Copied to clipboard

Flag this post as spam?

This post will be reported to the moderators as potential spam to be looked at


  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Sep 09, 2015 @ 18:27
    Ben
    0

    Umbraco Forms user input disappearing after validation

    I have installed and licensed Umbraco Forms on one of my websites and I think I am not understanding how the validation works. Is it normal for the form to loose all the user input if the user didn't fill out a required fields? Is there something that I am missing that would keep the user's input after validation? I have previously created forms with .NET and haven't run into this issue before.

    I am attaching a before and after screenshot. Just wondering how to keep the user input after validation.

    (Before Validation) enter image description here

    (After Validation) enter image description here

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Sep 14, 2015 @ 17:47
    Ben
    0

    Has anyone else experienced this?

    In case it matters I am using this in Webforms and not in MVC.

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Sep 21, 2015 @ 16:50
    Ben
    0

    Could anyone confirm if this is the expected behavior or not?

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Sep 24, 2015 @ 13:53
    Ben
    0

    At this point Umbraco Forms is unusable for our site. Can anyone help?

    We really don't want the people filling out the forms (some of which are long forms) to have to re-type anything if they missed something.

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Sep 30, 2015 @ 13:59
    Ben
    0

    Help?

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Oct 06, 2015 @ 17:43
    Ben
    0

    bump

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Oct 19, 2015 @ 13:31
    Ben
    0

    Other than the user input disappearing when the form validates, Umbraco Forms have been working pretty well. We just need the user's input to stay when the form validation runs.

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Nov 11, 2015 @ 14:51
    Ben
    0

    I still haven't found a solution to this problem and am regretting buying this add on.

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Nov 30, 2015 @ 17:59
    Ben
    0

    Does anyone know if this is an MVC vs Web Form issue? Please help.

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Dec 17, 2015 @ 13:26
    Ben
    0

    Is this question in the right category?

  • Stijn Van Assche 3 posts 73 karma points
    Dec 17, 2015 @ 13:47
    Stijn Van Assche
    0

    Hi Ben,

    I just created a simple form with validation; everything works as expected -> no user input is cleared.

    I'm using Umbraco v7.3.4 and Forms v 4.1.4. What versions are you using?

    Kr, Stijn.

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Dec 17, 2015 @ 13:52
    Ben
    0

    Hi Stijn,

    I am using v7.2.8. I am not sure what version of Forms I am using, how do I find that?

    I am looking at upgrading Umbraco to 7.3.4 next week.

  • Stijn Van Assche 3 posts 73 karma points
    Dec 17, 2015 @ 13:54
    Stijn Van Assche
    0

    I installed Forms using NuGet; there you can see the version number.

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Dec 17, 2015 @ 14:25
    Ben
    0

    I found the version here: \App_Plugins\UmbracoForms\version

    Looks like I am on v4.1.4

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Dec 17, 2015 @ 21:59
    Ben
    100

    I have setup a test server and upgraded Umbraco from v7.2.8 to v7.3.0 and now there is no postback for validation and the data stays in their fields. Looks like it might have been a bug with Umbraco v7.2.8.

    Thanks for your help Stijn!

  • ljcooper 21 posts 86 karma points
    Feb 02, 2016 @ 21:55
    ljcooper
    0

    I'm having the same issue with Umbraco 7.3.1 and forms 4.1.5 - any insights?

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Feb 03, 2016 @ 13:19
    Ben
    0

    I would try upgrading to v7.3.4. I am on that version of Umbraco and it seems to be working for me.

  • ljcooper 21 posts 86 karma points
    Feb 03, 2016 @ 13:38
    ljcooper
    0

    I'll give that a shot and I'll report back!

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Feb 04, 2016 @ 14:46
    Ben
    0

    I just tried it and found that it is not working. The Umbraco form is doing what it was doing previously if validation fails. Looks like it worked in Umbraco v7.3.0, but then stopped working after I upgraded.

    I am going to try upgrading Umbraco Forms to v4.1.5.

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Feb 04, 2016 @ 14:59
    Ben
    0

    Yeah, looks like it is broken again :(

    I am going to re-post this because I don't see how I can unmark it being solved.

  • ljcooper 21 posts 86 karma points
    Feb 04, 2016 @ 15:10
    ljcooper
    0

    The upgrade did not help.

    So, we wrote a band-aid script to disable the submit button as long as mandatory fields were not filled in - obviously we'd like to see it fixed since regexp validation and the captcha still erases all user-entered data, but we can limp along for now. I find it surprising that no one else is seeing this issue.

    Thanks for reposting!

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Mar 11, 2016 @ 20:21
    Ben
    0

    Forgot to post the link to the issue tracker:

    http://issues.umbraco.org/issue/U4-8105

  • ljcooper 21 posts 86 karma points
    Apr 01, 2016 @ 18:41
    ljcooper
    0

    Completely different installation than my first report - same behavior, and multi step forms will not proceed past the first step - @Ben are you seeing anything like the multi step form issue on your affected instances?

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Apr 01, 2016 @ 18:46
    Ben
    0

    I haven't tried multi forms yet. When I get a chance, I will test it out on my end and see what happens.

  • Ben 112 posts 398 karma points
    Apr 01, 2016 @ 19:05
    Ben
    0

    I just tried creating a multi step form, but I am not sure if I did it correctly. Here is what I did to create the multi step form:

    1. Created two separate forms (one called "Test Form 1" and the other called "Test Form 2"
    2. Test Form 1 had one required text field to enter a name
    3. Test Form 2 had one required textarea field to enter a favorite color
    4. Created a test page for Test Form 1 and Test Form 2
    5. I had Test Form 1 redirect to the page with Test Form 2 on it

    As long as I filled in the required fields it looks like the values were saved. However, the two forms aren't linked in anyway. I think I need to do some more research on how to setup a multi step form with Umbraco Forms.

Please Sign in or register to post replies

Write your reply to:

Draft